6 minute read

Web-Based EDI vs Fully Automated EDI: What’s the Difference?

As those using fully automated managed EDI systems will attest, by streamlining key B2B processes and freeing up internal resources, EDI can prove hugely conducive to business growth. For many businesses web-based EDI (or Web EDI) is a key part of the way in which they automate their supply chains – as we explain in depth here. For the small and mid-sized suppliers using their partners’ Web EDI portals, however, the reality of web-based EDI can be very different, with navigation between multiple customer portals and manual data entry proving extremely time and resource-intensive. 

Unfortunately, despite being well aware of the issues with web-based EDI, many businesses neglect to consider moving to a fully automated solution as they are either unaware of the substantial benefits of doing so or believe migration will be extremely complicated.

Admittedly, identifying the benefits of moving from a web-based to a fully automated EDI solution, and when best to do so, can be tricky, with different providers all saying different things. To help elucidate, this article explores the real difference between web-based and fully automated EDI, providing you with a clear picture so you can make the right decision for your business moving forward.

Starting out – web-based EDI

For many businesses, the first interaction with EDI comes as a result of a large retail customer requiring EDI capability from their trading partners. In order to enable their suppliers to trade with them efficiently, these larger customers will generally provide access to a web-based EDI portal. 

Naturally, as supply chain businesses grow, so do their trading partner networks. As such, in time many smaller and mid-sized suppliers quickly find themselves having to manage B2B data exchange via multiple web-based EDI portals. This in turn can compromise growth, efficiency and profits, as exchanging commerce critical information becomes increasingly complicated and resource-heavy.

Where most businesses go wrong

Unfamiliar with the key differences between web-based EDI and fully automated solutions, many organisations purchase their own web-based EDI package in order to simplify document exchange by removing the need to access multiple customer portals. However, while this consolidation admittedly saves some time, it fails to combat the main business problem that EDI was developed to fix – time-consuming and error-prone manual data entry.

As illustrated in the diagram below, although the communication between your web-based EDI platform and your partners may be automated, seamless integration between your EDI portal and your ERP system is not possible. This means that all information must be manually transferred. In essence you’re paying to do business with those customers who require EDI, without experiencing any of the benefits of EDI yourself.

Web-based EDI

How does fully automated EDI differ from web-based EDI?

The key difference between web-based and fully automated EDI is the fact that the latter allows your business partners’ ERP system effectively to talk directly to your own, bypassing the need for human intervention. Individual documents are then automatically available in your ERP system and can be searched for and edited in your existing user interface.

Fully automated EDI

By removing the need for manual data entry, both error rate and pressure on internal teams are greatly reduced. 

“What are the cost implications?”

Although web EDI offers suppliers the benefit of being able to expand their partner networks to include larger retailers, in terms of the cost-effectiveness of processing documents, web-based EDI is virtually the same as traditional paper/PDF communication. 

As illustrated in the figure below, the only real saving of moving from paper-based document exchange to web EDI is printing costs. On the other hand, moving from web-based EDI to fully automated EDI drastically reduces the number of steps to process a document. Thanks to seamless integration in the user’s ERP system, fully automated EDI requires only two steps for successful end-to-end exchange: generation and transmission.

Fully automated EDI Savings

While estimating the cost benefits of this process improvement is complicated, based on numerous reports from IBM, GS1 and others, the expected savings of moving to a fully automated system can be calculated at around 64%. This figure factors in FTE costs, opportunity costs of more value-adding activities, errors, delays and postage/fax fees (if relevant).

As we look at in our blog post on the topic, however, perhaps the biggest factor when it comes to achieving cost savings is making the right EDI supplier choice.

White Paper - Cost benefits of EDI
For a detailed exploration of the ROI you can expect from fully automated EDI, download our new white paper by clicking the image above

How is this process improvement achieved?

The key factor behind this streamlining of B2B document exchange is deep ERP integration.

Opting for a managed EDI solution offering deep integration (as opposed to relying on customers’ web-based EDI portals) means that when it comes to monitoring, accessing, troubleshooting or modifying messages, you can do it all directly in your ERP system. This allows businesses to self serve – avoiding delays and relieving pressure on in-house resources.

Unlike many other providers, ecosio offers deep ERP integration, creating a seamless UI experience thanks to our unique and powerful API. With several connectors capable of creating a fast link between ecosio and any ERP system, achieving unparalleled message status visibility is a simple process.

Differences at a glance

Web EDI Fully automated EDI
  • Time-consuming
  • Resource-heavy
  • Potential for human error
  • Hinders business growth
  • Different systems for each trading partner
  • Time-saving
  • Cost-saving
  • Reduces manual errors
  • Scalable (conducive to business growth)
  • Improved data visibility
  • Deep ERP integration possible

“So when should I make the switch?”

In general, a classic EDI solution is always preferable to a web EDI solution, because only with classic, managed EDI can the full automation potential of electronic data exchange be realised. However, in practice the transition to a fully automated system usually comes after a period of using web-based EDI portals.

As shown in the figure below, the use of web-based EDI becomes uneconomical beyond a certain volume of documents (and increasingly so as document volume increases over time).

Cost of web-based EDI

Want to learn more?

If you are a supplier looking to move from your customers’ web-based EDI portals to experiencing the benefits of fully automated EDI yourself, get in touch today. We’re happy to answer any questions you have!

most read

Keep on reading

6 minute read

Expert Perspective — Christoph Ebm: EDI Post-Covid

In this insightful interview, ecosio CEO Christoph Ebm shares his thoughts on supply chain resilience and what the future holds for EDI.

7 minute read

Choosing an EDI Platform - A Breakdown

Looking for advice and information on EDI platforms and what what to look for when deciding between the various options? Look no further!

7 minute read

A Guide to Efficient EDI Systems

In this article we break down what an EDI system is, what different types of system offer, and things to remember when selecting a solution.

9 minute read

EDI Integration: What is It and How Can It Help Your Business?

Efficient EDI integration can have a transformative effect on your business. Read our article to find out how it can benefit you.

4 minute read

The Most Common ANSI ASC X12 Party Identifiers and How to Use Them

ANSI X12 party identifiers are a common source of errors. In this article we explore how to avoid issues and what the most common X12 party identifiers are.

9 minute read

Using EDIFACT Parties Correctly - A Breakdown

Errors involving EDIFACT party codes (or EDIFACT parties) are a key cause of master data issues. Find out why.

8 minute read

What is Master Data Synchronisation and Why is it Needed?

Find out how conducting a master data synchronisation can make everyday EDI exchanges and partner onboarding easier and more efficient.

4 minute read

A Brief Introduction to Modern EDI Systems

Are you aware of what modern EDI systems can offer? In this article we explore the recent trend towards fully managed solutions.

5 minute read

The Three Most Common EDI Pitfalls

While EDI can offer substantial benefits, achieving the perfect solution isn't always easy. Read our article to find out where many go wrong.

4 minute read

The Five Top EDI Trends: Expert Forecast

In this article we explore five current EDI trends and the extent to which they reflect the future of EDI more widely.

10 minute read

Full Service EDI Explained

What is full service EDI (AKA fully managed EDI), what benefits can it offer your business and is it really the future of B2B integration?

5 minute read

How Easy is Handling EDI In-house?

Handling EDI in-house may seem like a simple solution, but do you know what setting up and running an EDI system really entails?

We use cookies to provide an optimal website experience. You decide which one you want to allow. Depending on the setting, however, not all functionalities may be available to you. Data protection & Imprint.